Applying Narrative Theories To Our Music Video

JC
by Joe Chamberlain112 views·Updated Mar 12, 2012
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

One of the binary opposites in the music video is the use of Day Vs. Night. This uses amplification as the song is called 'One Night In October'.

Vs.

Also, dry land vs. water. However, the video is ironic in the fact that a boat is on dry land.

Vs.

The name of the band also uses a binary opposition as they are 'The Skeleton Boys', but there is a girl member:

Todorov's theory of a 3-part narrative structure:

Todorov believed there was an equilibrium at the start of a video, this was then disrupted, and then restored.

I do not think the video uses this theory as the main theme is disjuncture. However, it could be seen as: at the start of the video, the band are all together playing their instruments:

They then all go out and have a good time:

and then all return together at the end of the video to be playing their instruments together again:

Laura Mulvey's theory 'The Male Gaze' believes that women are objectified and seen as objects by men. This is usually in a voyeuristic or sexually suggestive way.

This is not used at all in this music video as the female character has been purposefully dressed to look like a 'tom-boy' in order to make 'The Skeleton Boys' conventional. What this means is it would be quite contradictory if an extremely feminine character was in the band, so she has been modified to stand out less - so in a way, the video has purposefully avoided this theory in order to maintain 'The Skeleton Boys' 's masculine nature:

The theory of codes from Roland Barthes could be applied to this video. The idea of cultural codes is used in the video as the use of disjuncture does not give the video any narrative. There are parts of amplification, such as the 'Carlisle' signage, however, the majority is completely random and irrelevent to the lyrics. This may make the audience consider where the video could be taking them, or, they could see it as completely ignoring the theory of Roland Barthes as it is the video is too irrelevent to the lyrics in order to create a story.

Claude Levi-Strauss's Theory Of Binary Opposites

The music video refutes the theory of Andrew Goodwin that the visuals link in some way to the lyrics as the video is mainly disjuncture. However, parts of the video contain performance and in some parts amplification of lyrics. The idea of using disjuncture in the text is a binary opposite in itself as it doesn't link what should be linked.