Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card requiredGetting Over the Methodology Wars:
Comments on Howe
Howe’s (2009) critique of positivistic tendencies in the education research community is valuable and pertinent. His analysis is nonetheless one-sided, finding fault with one side of current divisions alone. In an effort to retain the good points of his analysis, the author first summarizes Howe’s argument, interpreting it as a critique of hasty and dogmatic reductionism. He then considers parallel problems arising from hasty and dogmatic holism that Howe does not address. Following this discussion, a third, temporal approach is suggested in which analytic
and synthetic perspectives are used to suggest and modify one another in a cycle, rather than being taken as fixed stances. Adopting this approach could help reduce the dogmatism evident in the methodology wars, although struggles for advantage would clearly remain.
Bredo's Critique
Howe’s critique is especially pertinent at a time when a narrow
emphasis on instrumental efficiency, a mechanistic conception of“what works,” and a narrow conception of science dominate education discourse. I think he is right that a new orthodoxy is afoot in some sectors of the education research community that is narrow, dogmatic, and harmful to freedom of thought. Howe’s analysis is also helpful in revealing similarities among debates polarizing the research community, debates whose relation to one another is seldom seen so clearly. In assisting us in thinking deeply about the values and assumptions underlying current conceptions of education research, he does exactly what a good philosopher of education should do.
Although sympathetic with much that Howe has written, I nevertheless fear that he has gone a bit overboard in attempting to bring about greater balance. Howe is critical only of a positivistic
approach to education research, making it seem as though all fault lies on that side on the polarities he analyzes. His interpretation is understandable given the politics of the time, but reaction
and counterreaction reinforce one another, resulting in mutually confirming cycles of divisiveness (Bateson, 1962).
Conclusions
First, and simplest, it would be better if those of analytic and synthetic temperament learned from one another rather than engaging in methodology wars.
Second, there is only one proper standard for education research: It should perform its function well. A good research project is one that clears up ambiguities in the situation it aims to resolve while opening up fruitful lines of future inquiry.
Third, statements of research standards should take account of C. S. Peirce’s (1898/1998) first rule of logic: “Do not block the way of inquiry” (p. 48). This is basically the same as the statement in the Hippocratic oath that one should, above all, do no harm. Standards are hints for how to do things well, not rules to follow slavishly. Standardization of thought will only impoverish, not improve, education research.
Fourth, although Howe’s article is extremely helpful in its criticism of the contemporary reincarnation of positivism, it is somewhat one-sided. I have tried to suggest a way of achieving greater balance by adopting a temporal approach in which different perspectives are used cyclically to guide and constrain one another.
Fifth, although there is much to recommend Phillips’s advocacy
of a postpositivistic middle ground, a more dynamic conception
of balance would consider how various perspectives can be used to achieve a common purpose by taking one another into
account rather than by adopting a midpoint between them.
Bredo's Response to Howe
The Value–Fact Hierarchy
The Qualitative–Quantitative Hierarchy
BREDO's
"Reductionism becomes hasty and dogmatic when it is presupposed that wholes—theories, ideas, plans, actions, and so forth—can be reduced to independently testable or implementable parts and the latter treated as given and secure foundations. Holism becomes hasty and dogmatic when it is presupposed that no reduction is possible without total loss of meaning, and security found only in wholes, which are also treated as given foundations. In other words, each orientation becomes rigid and dogmatic when it is believed to be the only true approach.
Seen in this way, each of the one-sided orientations dividing the education research community has something useful to contribute, especially when not adopted in a fixed or dogmatic fashion. Qualitative generalization within a case can assist quantitative generalization across cases, and vice-versa. In fact, neither makes much sense without the other. Judgments about fact and value may also be used to modify one another: Reflection on present aims or values helps in judging whether one is considering the correct facts, and inquiry into factual consequences helps in judging whether a given aim or value is truly valuable (Dewey, 1939). Scientific exploration of means and humanistic exploration of ends can and should inform one another in a society seeking to be both technically progressive and humane. Having a feel for the whole combined with technical accuracy of parts, each informing the other to achieve
something in common, is what is needed in any art, including that of social and education research (Dewey, 1934).
SUMMARY
1. Three Dogmas of Reductionism
The Quantitative–Qualitative Hierarchy
The Fact–Value Hierarchy
The Science–Humanities Hierarchy
Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.
Free to try, no credit card required