Systems Science Simulation & Knowledge Translation and Dissemination

EM
by Ernest Moy27 views·Updated Jul 9, 2014
Powered by AI

Need to present on this topic?

Create your own polished presentation in minutes. Just describe what you need.

Free to try, no credit card required

Transcript

Agent-based Model of Disparities: What Do Disparities Look Like?

Background

Disparities in health involve complex interactions among people, providers, & the environment

Agent-based models

  • Simulate complex interactions between agents & the environment
  • Allow controlled manipulation of micro-level behavior of agents to observe effects on macro-level phenomena

Non-majority people?

Space between lines?

Conclusions & Next Steps

Objectives

To develop agent-based models of health disparities that

  • Improve understanding of factors that contribute to disparities
  • Enable visualization of the generation of disparities
  • Can be used by policymakers to design better disparities interventions
  • Can be used by public health educators to teach students about disparities

Agent-based models of disparities

  • Provide insight into the complex interaction of factors that contribute to disparities in health
  • Illustrate how disparities happen
  • May enable better interventions to reduce disparities
  • May help students learn about health disparities

Next steps

  • Use data on your city to model your disparities
  • Add other elements that affect disparities

Information Dissemination is Mostly Digital

Reading is in Retreat

Digital Media Allow Person-Centered Information Dissemination

System Science Simulation

Types of System Science Simulation

Getting Results

Modeling Software

Why Simulate Systems?

(Sterman, AJPH 2006)

Network Structure Characteristics

Bridge collapses

Breadth

Density

Centralization

Retrum J H et al. Health Educ Behav 2013;40:13S-23S

Copyright © by Society for Public Health Education

System Dynamics Model Stock and Flow Diagram

Use sliders to set parameters

Press ‘setup’ button to allocate people & resources to the two sides

Press ‘go’ button to start simulation

Watch counters for sick & dead people

Simulation ends when 100 people have died

At default, sick & death rates should be higher among brown vs. pink people & on the East vs. West

Wakeland W et al. Health Educ Behav 2013;40:74S-86S

Copyright © by Society for Public Health Education

Network

  • Focus on structure
  • Who

Dynamic

  • Focus on process
  • How

Agent-based

  • Focus on heterogeneity of processes
  • Where, who

Evolution of methods for seeking scientific truth

  • Rationalism (Greek Philosophers)
  • Observation in natural environment
  • No modification of conditions
  • Empiricism (Scientific Method)
  • Experimentation in artificial environment
  • Vary one condition at a time
  • Simulation
  • Recreation of system in virtual environment
  • Vary multiple conditions

Dynamic Complexity

  • Feedback: Actions change the system producing “side effects” and nonlinear relationships
  • Time delays: Proximate costs & distal benefits
  • Stocks and flows: Net accumulation

Barriers to Learning

  • Limited information: Looking where you have data
  • Bounded rationality: Looking where you think the answer is
  • Resistance to failure

Free download

Extensive documentation & tutorials

Modeling Commons to share & show models on-line (requires Java)

Adult Literacy, 1992 & 2003

Agent-Based Model of Rise of Civilization, 1500 BC – 1500 AD

Pros & Cons with Digital Media

As with Other Media

Source: National Center for Education Statistics, 1992 National Adult Literacy Survey (NALS) and 2003 National Assessment of Adult Literacy (NAAL)

Adult Literacy by Sex, 1992 & 2003

Socrates on Letters

...this discovery of yours will create forgetfulness in the learners’ souls, because they will not use their memories; they will trust to the external written characters and not remember of themselves. The specific which you have discovered is an aid not to memory, but to reminiscence, and you give your disciples not truth, but only the semblance of truth; they will be hearers of many things and will have learned nothing; they will appear to be omniscient and will generally know nothing; they will be tiresome company, having the show of wisdom without the reality.

Women

Men

Source: National Center for Education Statistics, 1992 National Adult Literacy Survey (NALS) and 2003 National Assessment of Adult Literacy (NAAL)

Modeling Disparities

Model Elements: Geography

Resources are different on the West & East sides

Sliders are used to set effects of these resources when a person walks next to one

Pink & brown people are allocated to the West & East in proportion to Non-Hispanic Whites & other racial/ethnic groups in the 2010 US Census

Segregation: When people reproduce, they generate children based on side

Health Care Disparities: Sliders are used to set different health benefits from doctor’s offices for pink & brown people

Google Map of DC

  • Place parks (green) & highways (black)
  • Mold diamond into square
  • Divide city into West & East sides (16th St.)

Model Elements: Built Environment

Model Elements: People

Two races to model disparities (pink & brown people)

Random Actions

  • Walk
  • Get sick (turn green)
  • Recover from sickness
  • Die, if health < 0 (turn into ghost)
  • Reproduce (by fission to avoid extinction)

US Census 2010 ZIP Code Business Patterns

  • Calculate # per 2500 population on each side
  • Large grocery stores (yellow buildings)
  • Fitness centers (bicycles)
  • Doctor’s offices (doctor figures)

US Environmental Protection Agency

  • # on each side of Superfund Sites (cow skulls)

Numbers of resources on each side are programmed but placement is random

System Science Simulation & Knowledge Translation and Dissemination

Ernest Moy, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality